LEIPZIG, 16 NOVEMBER 2026 — The case against the Neanderthals was built out of skulls, and for most of the last century the skulls were read as evidence of a mind that had taken a different road and stopped. Longer front to back than ours. Lower in the vault. And at the back of the head, a shelf of bone — the occipital bun — that seemed to say something specific: a large visual cortex, a great deal of brain spent on seeing, less left over for the faculties we had decided to be proud of.
On 16 November, in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, Hugo Zeberg and Svante Pääbo published a result that makes that century of reading harder rather than easier. A common variant in the human genome that shrinks part of the occipital lobe — the cuneus, a fold on the inner surface at the back of the brain — was not invented by us. It came from Neanderthals.
Each copy a living person carries is worth about 0.85 cubic centimetres less cuneus, an effect on that structure larger than any other variant known; by one measurement, carriers’ occipital lobes are roughly a tenth smaller in volume. And the same variant is associated with something nobody was looking for in a story about brain size: in people who carry two copies, the risk of schizophrenia is about 10 per cent lower.
The variant that shrinks the visual brain, in other words, is also the variant that appears to protect it from one of the most heritable disorders of the mind. Then comes the turn that keeps the paper in the conversation. Neanderthals had larger occipital lobes than we do. The variant they gave us makes ours smaller. The debt runs against the direction of the loan.
The bone deserves its own paragraph, because everything rests on how much of a brain a skull can be made to confess. A cranium is a mould of the brain taken from the outside, and the inside of that mould — the endocast, in the older literature — reproduces the cortex the way a pillow reproduces a face: the gross divisions, the big sulci, the relative proportions of the lobes, and nothing of the tissue.
On that coarse scale the difference between the two species is real and repeatable. Neanderthal braincases are elongated, flattened front to back, widest toward the rear; modern human braincases are globular, with a high rounded vault and a bulging parietal region, a shape that appears late and quickly in our own fossil record. The Neanderthal occipital region is, cast after cast, relatively larger. Averaged across the catalogue the Neanderthal brain is not smaller than ours — if anything slightly larger — which makes the shape the interesting part.
From shape, generations of palaeoanthropologists inferred a shift in the internal budget: more cortex assigned to the back of the head, to vision, to the machinery of a body and a landscape that may have demanded it. Marcellin Boule’s reconstruction of the old man of La Chapelle-aux-Saints, published in 1911, turned that inference into a hunched, ape-like brute; much of the posture was an artefact of the specimen’s severe arthritis, and the correction took decades. La Ferrassie 1, lifted from a rock shelter in 1909, carries the same low long vault and the same bun. The skull is not a blank, in other words. It says, in a voice nobody now disputes, that the two brains were built on different plans. What it cannot say is why, or by which letters.
Zeberg and Pääbo went looking for the letters. Their method is a filter with a strong prior. A variant in living people that came from Neanderthals should satisfy three conditions at once: high frequency in Neanderthal genomes, presence in some living populations, and absence from people of entirely sub-Saharan ancestry, whose ancestors by and large never met a Neanderthal.
The pair worked with the five Neanderthal genomes detailed enough to be searched base by base, and with the two Denisovan genomes sequenced so far. The variant cleared every gate. It sits in all five Neanderthals. It is absent from both Denisovans, a cousin species — so it is not simply a property of archaic hominins in general. And in living people it is confined to populations with non-African ancestry.
The last step of the argument is arithmetic that has become standard in the field and is still worth spelling out. The variant lies inside a stretch of DNA 59.7 kilobases long that carries the Neanderthal pattern throughout. A segment inherited from a shared ancestor would have been broken up by recombination over hundreds of thousands of years into a fragment far too small to recognise.
A block that size entered the human gene pool whole, when the two species met in the last 50,000 to 60,000 years, and has not yet had time to dissolve. The variant itself is a deletion: four nucleotides missing on chromosome 14. It was first described in 2019, in a genome-wide study of the volume of the brain’s lobes, as a locus for occipital volume — and nothing more; its archaic origin is a much later reading.
It lies not in a gene but in the predicted recognition motifs for transcription factors, beside DAAM1 — a gene whose protein helps build and organise the actin cytoskeleton, and which has been tied to the planar cell polarity pathways that shape a developing nervous system. Carriers, the authors report, show altered DAAM1 expression. The four missing letters are not a broken part. They are a change in the settings.
Then the part that turns a genetic curiosity into a number. The authors brought the variant to the UK Biobank, which holds genotypes for half a million volunteers and brain images for a subset of them, and to the 1000 Genomes Project for the population picture. In the imaging data, each copy of the Neanderthal allele is associated with a cuneus about 0.85 cubic centimetres smaller.
Two copies, twice the subtraction. Reported as a proportion, carriers’ occipital lobes come out about ten per cent smaller in volume than those of people carrying the ordinary, non-Neanderthal version of the same stretch of chromosome. The cuneus is a wedge-shaped fold on the medial face of the occipital lobe, between the calcarine and the parieto-occipital sulci, part of the earliest cortical handling of what the eye brings in; it is not the whole of vision, and a smaller cuneus is not the same as seeing less well.
Zeberg’s own gloss on the magnitude is the line that will be quoted: “If you ordered a shot at a bar, that’s about how much brain volume it is.” About 20 per cent of people of European descent carry at least one copy — a figure that should stop anyone inclined to read this as a defect. A variant at that frequency, moving a structure of that size, spread across a continent, is not a rare accident. It is part of the ordinary equipment.
The finding that made the paper news is the one with nothing to do with seeing. In the same data, people carrying two copies of the Neanderthal variant were about 10 per cent less likely to have been diagnosed with schizophrenia — “almost 10%” in the paper’s own wording. Two qualifications keep this from becoming a headline about a Neanderthal gene against madness.
The first is that the association belongs to this one variant and not to Neanderthal ancestry as a whole: the authors checked, and the genome-wide proportion of Neanderthal DNA shows no such tendency, which makes the effect a property of a particular regulatory change rather than of being, in some overall sense, more Neanderthal. The second is that the mechanism is unknown. “We don’t know the details behind that interaction,” Pääbo said. “The gene is involved in many aspects of brain development.”
What the variant does not do is make people cleverer or duller. The paper examined cognition and schooling and found at most about two weeks of additional education per allele, against an average of roughly 15 years — a difference small enough to be an artefact of very large samples.
The temptation, which the authors raise and then decline to endorse, is that the two findings fit an old speculation: that the human cognitive package, with its unusual appetite for invention, arrived with a raised risk of psychosis, and that the Neanderthal version of this switch keeps some of the protection our own version traded away. “That would all be speculative,” Pääbo said.
“I think what we can say is that it was at least not very bad to carry it.” One loose thread is worth naming here: in 2021, Karen Berman and colleagues at the National Institute of Mental Health reported that people with more Neanderthal ancestry overall had lower rates of schizophrenia — a different framing from this paper’s careful “not ancestry in general,” and a reminder that “more Neanderthal” is not one quantity but a sum of thousands of separately behaving pieces.
Which brings the argument back to the bone, and to the objection the paper cannot answer. Thomas Schoenemann, an anthropologist and cognitive scientist at Indiana University Bloomington, put it plainly: if this variant did in Neanderthals what it appears to do in us, their occipital lobes ought to be relatively small. The casts say they were large.
Either the variant behaved differently in the genome that evolved it — plausible, since its effect depends on the company it keeps, and a Neanderthal genome is not a human genome with a few archaic inserts — or the cuneus and the occipital lobe are not the same story, or the skull’s message has been over-read after all. “It calls into question what exactly we can say about its effects in Neanderthals at all,” Schoenemann said.
The authors do not claim otherwise: the paper’s finding is about present-day humans, and it is careful to say so. What it adds is a piece of population history that sits oddly with any simple story of benefit. Tracking the variant across ancient and modern genomes, Zeberg and Pääbo found that its frequency has stayed roughly constant for tens of thousands of years. Evolution has neither swept it to fixation nor purged it — the signature of something close to neutral in the currency selection actually trades in.
That makes the 20 per cent frequency in Europeans, against the 1 to 2 per cent average of Neanderthal ancestry, a matter of drift, of the founder populations that carried it out of Africa and into Europe, and possibly of small local advantages that never added up to a sweep.
Why the cuneus shrank, what altered DAAM1 expression does to a developing cortex, whether the association with schizophrenia survives in a cohort that is not overwhelmingly European — these are the questions the paper hands on. Organoids and animal models are the next instrument, and the honest position remains the one Zeberg stated: the mechanics are not understood.
Step back from the specifics and the paper becomes a lesson in what a genome is. We tend to speak of Neanderthal ancestry as a stain or a residue — one or two per cent of our DNA, a souvenir of an encounter that ended badly for one of the parties. That framing gets the direction of the relationship wrong. The archaic contribution is not a smudge on a finished text; it is a set of working parts, some of them running inside the most consequential organ we have.
A regulatory switch carried by one European in five, sitting in the predicted binding sites of transcription factors, adjusting the expression of a gene that organises the cytoskeleton of developing neurons, and leaving its signature in the volume of a fold at the back of the brain — that is not a relic. It is equipment in service. That it also shifts the odds of a psychiatric diagnosis is the kind of coupling genetics keeps turning up and our categories keep failing to expect.
Forty thousand years after the last Neanderthals died, four missing letters on chromosome 14 are still tuning the back of the human head, in a direction that runs opposite to the skulls which first told us the two species were different. The old man of La Chapelle, reconstructed as a brute, was a lesson in how easily bone is made to serve an argument. The lesson of this paper is subtler and harder to be smug about: the brain we call ours is a compromise reached in a hurry between at least two lineages, and parts of the compromise are still being audited.
• The paper: Hugo Zeberg & Svante Pääbo, “A Neandertal-derived genetic variant reduces occipital brain volume in present-day humans,” PNAS 123 (48), e2624837123, published online 16 November 2026, print issue 1 December 2026, DOI 10.1073/pnas.2624837123, PMID 43038442. Zeberg: Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology, Leipzig, and Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm. Pääbo: Max Planck Institute, Leipzig, and the Okinawa Institute of Science and Technology. Both are corresponding authors.
• The variant: a deletion of four nucleotides on chromosome 14, inside a 59.7-kilobase block that carries the Neanderthal pattern; first described in 2019 in a genome-wide association study of lobar brain volume (van der Lee et al., Communications Biology 2, 285) as a locus for occipital volume. It lies in predicted transcription-factor recognition motifs near DAAM1, and carriers show altered DAAM1 expression.
• Distribution: present in all five detailed Neanderthal genomes; absent from both Denisovan genomes sequenced so far; in living humans confined to non-African ancestry. About 20% of people of European descent carry at least one copy (as reported by Science).
• Effect on the brain: 0.85 cm³ less cuneus volume per copy — an effect larger than that of any other known variant on that structure. Two copies therefore about 1.7 cm³. Carriers’ occipital lobes measured in the UK Biobank imaging subset were about 10% smaller in volume than non-carriers’ (reported by Science); the per-copy figure is the paper’s own.
• Schizophrenia: risk reduced by “almost 10%” in homozygotes (paper). The paper explicitly states that Neanderthal ancestry as a whole shows no such tendency. Karen Berman’s 2021 study reported lower schizophrenia rates in people with more Neanderthal ancestry overall — a different measure, and not a contradiction to be resolved by either side alone.
• Cognition: at most two weeks of additional schooling per allele against an average of about 15 years — small or nonexistent (paper). The creative-trade-off interpretation is raised by the authors as speculation and left there.
• Not claimed: that Neanderthals had small occipital lobes (they did not), that the variant caused their anatomy, that it directly causes or prevents schizophrenia, or that carrying more Neanderthal DNA is protective in general. Mechanism unknown; organoids and animal models proposed as the next step.
• Critique on the record: Thomas Schoenemann (Indiana University Bloomington) notes that the occipital-volume link is not a clean result, since the same variant in Neanderthals should have produced small occipital lobes, and did not.
• Sources: paper (DOI above); Nature News, 16 Nov 2026; Science News, 16 Nov 2026; Scientific American, 16 Nov 2026; Smithsonian, 18 Nov 2026.
[심층 리포트] 뼈와 유전자가 서로 다른 말을 할 때 — 네안데르탈인이 남긴 네 글자
라이프치히, 2026년 11월 16일 — 네안데르탈인에 대한 판결은 뼈로 내려졌다. 지난 한 세기 동안 그 뼈는 ‘다른 길로 가다 멈춘 정신’의 증거로 읽혔다. 우리보다 앞뒤로 길고, 정수리는 낮았다. 그리고 뒤통수에는 뼈가 선반처럼 튀어나온 자리가 있었다. 후두융기(occipital bun)라 불리는 그 자리는 꽤 구체적인 말을 하는 듯했다.
Korean Version: [심층 리포트] 뼈와 유전자가 서로 다른 말을 할 때 — 네안데르탈인이 남긴 네 글자
Socko/Ghost


